Making your homemade pet treats more festive can start with holiday theme shapes, but you can also ‘spruce’ up treats. They make great gifts for the pet-lovers on your list, including pet-sitters, dog walkers, groomers, etc. They’re also fantastic fundraisers.

Below are some ideas to make your homemade pet treats more festive in healthy, natural ways. Remember that not all will be safe for all species of pets – always research before feeding.

Tip: Glaze treats with egg yolk to make powdered decorations adhere to the surface.

Naturally Festive Decorations for Homemade Pet Treats

Vegetables – Bell peppers come in red, gold and green, and there’s lots more pet-safe (varies by species) vegetables to choose from for a nutritious Christmas theme. Chopped tomato, spinach, swiss chard, broccoli, and cauliflower are just a few. Mix them in or decorate the top.

Fruit – Juicy berries like strawberries can be finely chopped and mixed into pet treat yogurt icing for a pink & red effect. Powdered freeze-dried fruit makes very pretty sprinkles on pet treats.  Freeze-dried fruit can create some cool effects if you rehydrate them and used the ‘juice’ as a substitute for the liquid in your recipe, along with the actual fruit.

Ground Krill – Sparkling orange. Mix with powdered seaweed/algae for more color and even more health benefits.

Carob Powder – Get the cocoa dusted look with Carob powder.

Ground Seaweed/Algae – More bio-available vitamins and minerals than any plant in the world and lots of classic Christmas color. Seaweed doesn’t have the binding issues of terrestrial plants and it’s low in carbohydrates. Cats love the smell. Mix it into homemade pet treats or press into the top to decorate.

Cinnamon – Safe and beneficial for most pets and a holiday favorite.

Calcium Montmorillonite Clay – Get a confectioner’s sugar look by sifting Calcium Montmorillonite Clay on homemade pet treats. It offers a holiday bonus of being a very healthy mineral supplement, digestive aid, and has anti-parasite properties.

Natural Food Coloring for Pets

You can purchase natural food dyes derived from plant sources quite easily these days. Processing limits the nutritional value of natural food coloring, however, so you may want to try using whole foods such as:

Green: A little Chlorella or Spirulina Algae will give you a deep green color. Powdered Green Tea will produce a lighter green.

Red: Paprika, Elder Berries, Raspberry or Cranberry juice. Concentrated fruit juice is often recommended for homemade food coloring, but with pets we have to check the labels. Many flavored juices include grape juice or other ‘base’ juices, added sugar, etc.

Yellow: Turmeric is a very healthy, standard source of yellow. You can also crush a little Saffron and steep in boiling water for a rich gold.

Blue:  We use mashed blueberries and/or blueberry juice for natural blue food coloring and a wonderful dose of antioxidants.

Do you have any suggestions for more festive pet treat recipes? We would also love to see your homemade holiday decorated pet treats!

✔ You may also be interested in reading:
Natural Dog Treat Recipe – Seasonal Seaweedies
Holistic Canine Cranberry Christmas Cookie Recipe


© All Natural Pet Care BlogContent on this website may not be used elsewhere without expressed permission. Thank you for respecting the effort that we have put into our original content.

DISCLOSURE: We may receive compensation for links to products on this website.

DISCLAIMER: Statements on this website may not have been evaluated by the FDA, Health Canada nor any other government regulator. The information and products provided by are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, nor prevent any disease and are intended for educational purposes only. READ MORE…

COMMENTS ARE MODERATED – Legitimate comments will be published after a short delay. Spam will not be published.

5 thoughts on “Add Naturally Festive Color to Homemade Pet Cookie Recipes

  1. I’m going to use some of these ideas in our dog bakery. I love finding new natural pet treat ideas, please publish more of them.

  2. I’ll be trying the ideas for Valentines Day dog treats. We’re having a little party…………I wish you could come!

Comments are closed.