By Jacques Bouchard

For a beginning aquarist, choosing the right gravel (substrate) for your tank can seem as simple as choosing your favorite color and running with it. And while the “curb appeal” of an aquarium — its gravel and decorations — are definitely a major part of the hobby’s appeal, there’s a lot your gravel can do for your aquarium’s beauty, as well as the health and behavior of your fish.

What you choose for your substrate is, both literally and figuratively, the foundation of your aquarium, and a little planning can go a long way to a beautiful, successful system. Before committing to an aquarium substrate, take a moment to ask yourself these four questions:

1. Why Use Aquarium Gravel At All?

In some cases, the wise choice could be to not have any aquarium substrate at all. This is most common when an aquarist has many tanks and keeps a small one empty as a “hospital” tank for sick fish. It’s also common when a fish owner is keeping large fish in a tank that may be too small for them. In these cases, a no-gravel approach aids in waste removal, allowing the owner to keep things extremely clean when doing water changes.

Generally speaking, however, adding gravel to your aquarium is a wise choice. In particular, gravel becomes the home of beneficial bacteria that will break down ammonia from fish urine and waste into nitrites, and then transform nitrites into nitrates, which are less toxic for the fish. They also become anchors for the roots of live plants, which can do wonders to add beauty, balance your water chemistry, and add oxygen to the water.

Depending on what you use, your aquarium substrate can have an impact on the overall water chemistry of the tank. For example, adding crushed coral or aragonite will harden water, add a PH buffer, and often add minerals to the water that are beneficial to some types of fish.

With that in mind, if you’re selecting a colored gravel, you’ll want to make sure that it’s been created with a “polymer seal”. The dyes in the aquarium are not always healthy for the fish if they bleed into the water, and these seals can help to protect them. They can be very intense too – I’ve ruined strainers permanently with the dyes off bags of black gravel.

2. What Will Be Living In Your Aquarium?

Choosing the right gravel or substrate for your aquarium should be based on what’s living there, including:

If your fish will be living in it: Many species of fish, such as stingrays (There is a freshwater variant!) or Kuhli loaches will try to hide in your substrate, and they’ll need fine-grained materials to survive there without being harmed. Scavenging fish such as goldfish can also have larger pieces of gravel become lodged in their mouths as they forage for food. All fish will come in contact with gravel from time to time, so the best gravel should be round-edged to avoid scratching. If your aquarium inhabitants are big waste producers like large catfish or turtles, large-grain gravel or even glass marbles are the easiest to vacuum, and could be the best choice for you.

If you have live plants: Plants have roots and delicate stems, and unless you’re using dirt as your substrate (which is best left to the experts), they’ll be hungry for nutrients. Large gravel can damage stems as you plant them, and the roots hold better to smaller-grade gravel. Sand offers a lot of hold for roots, but deeper areas of sand can develop anaerobic bacteria (bacteria that grows without oxygen), which is thought to deter root growth.

Generally, fine gravel is a cost-effective choice that works well with plants. A better but much more expensive choice is to purchase “activated gravel” — a porous, nutrient-rich gravel that provides out-of-the-bag readiness for planted tanks. Along with this, some dedicated aquarists will create layers in their tank that promote healthy plant growth, such as adding a layer of peat moss to provide needed minerals for plant growth.

If you keep snails: Common aquarium snails (sometimes referred to as “pest snails”) can be a benefit to your aquarium’s gravel bed. Two of the three common types of snails found in aquariums — Physa and Trumpet snails – are known to burrow into the gravel, with trumpet snails being particularly enthusiastic burrowers.

Unfortunately, Trumpet snails are also extremely prolific and nearly impossible to eliminate from an aquarium once a population is established. Additionally, they can begin to look bedraggled as they reach a point where there’s hundreds roaming your aquarium, and they’ve bred beyond their food supply. The other burrower, Physa snails, are easier to control but don’t churn up the substrate as well. Ramshorn snails are easier to control and even come in brown, gold, blue, and pink varieties, but will only clean the surface of the gravel.

If you want to deter snails from growing in your aquarium, large-grain gravel is hardest for the burrowers to hide in, and the best way to go.

4 Aquarium Gravel Questions That Will Make Or Break Your Tank - Pest Snails
Above, from left to right: Trumpet snail, Ramshorn snail, Physa snails.

3. What Will It Look Like?

Bubbling treasure chest ornaments and neon-pink gravel adds a fun look to your aquarium, but it also moves the focus away from the fish and on to the decorations. If you prefer this approach, there’s many ways to create that environment in a healthy aquarium. Be sure to do your research on each item you choose — many of the very common aquarium substrates and decorations (like plastic plants) can be very harmful to your fish. It’s also a good idea to plan for your gravel vacuuming as you place your ornaments, as you will want to be able to access your gravel without damaging your setup.

It’s very popular, particularly in Europe, to create a “planted” aquarium — an aquatic garden with minimal fish. If your focus is on the plants, many aquascapers prefer brightly-colored gravel as the best complement to the natural green foliage. In the long run, however, planted aquariums usually include a “ground cover” plant, such as baby tears or grasses, which cover the visible part of the substrate in plants. In this case, your top priority would be to create a layer of substrate that will help these plants grow.

If you’d like to highlight the beauty of brightly-colored fish, a darker-toned gravel is usually the best choice, as it can best highlight their natural colors. Additionally, darker colors tend to have a calming effect on fish, and the lower stress levels help to bring our their most vibrant colors.

Personally, I buy fish for their behavior and personality, and rarely own brightly-colored fish. My approach has always been to pick a neutral-toned substrate and build the aquarium to look like as natural a setting as possible, highlighting plants, layout, and the fish themselves equally. The picture below is of my 72-gallon bowfront setup.

4 Questions About Aquarium Gravel That Will Make Or Break Your Tank
A neutral gravel color may be ideal for aquariums where you’d like a natural feel.

4. Where Are You Putting Your Gravel (And How Much Is There)?

How thick your aquarium gravel layer should be has been hotly debated in forums and communities over recent years.

The “old” way of thinking is to use a deep layer of gravel to house bacteria and create space for deep plant roots. Recently, however, this practice has been contested by aquarists who point out that deep gravel and sand beds trap debris and may promote anaerobic bacteria growth that can lead to harmful hydrogen sulfide gas pockets, as well as deter root growth (anaerobic bacteria is also an important piece to the cycle of breaking down ammonia). It’s also true that using a gravel vacuum on deep layers of gravel will send old waste and debris into the aquarium, causing harmful spikes in levels of ammonia, nitrites, and nitrates.

In my experience, plants have thrived in gravel layers of many different thicknesses – or even in no substrate at all. I’ve seen aquarium roots plow through more than ten inches of gravel and bunch up at the bottom of an aquarium, and have had small aquarium fish live for seven years or more in the same aquariums. The trick seems to be to vacuum only the surface layer of the gravel, rarely going for a “deep dive” of more than three inches into the substrate.

I use a layer of gravel about five inches deep, but never clean all the way to the ground when vacuuming. On the rare occasion when I change the gravel, I remove the fish entirely and house them in a different aquarium overnight afterwards, doing a heavy water change and adding new filter media before moving the fish back in.

Whatever you choose, be creative with your gravel setup! Have fun with the process! Who says it has to be a single layer along the bottom of your aquarium? Develop a unique look to your aquarium by varying the depth of your gravel in various areas and creating unique areas and setups.

For example, I love to create catfish caves with gravel on top, and plant roots growing through the gravel into the cave. I do this by building a cave with a rock wall along the edges, using aquarium silicone to seal the rocks together (see photo below). I add a layer of large-grain gravel, which clogs up any small holes, then fill the rest of of the space with fine-grain gravel. The effect is quite unique!

4 Aquarium Gravel Questions That Will Make Or Break Your Tank
Having multiple depths to your aquarium gravel can add appeal to the tank, and lends itself to caves for your bottom-dwelling inhabitants.

Guest Author Bio:
This guest post was contributed by Jacques Bouchard, an aquarist of 20 years and Senior Digital Marketing Strategist at DragonSearch. Follow him on Twitter at @DSFido to find more of his articles on aquariums, or to ask any questions you may have about your own tank setup.

✔ You may also be interested in reading:
DIY Natural Fertilizer Balls for Aquarium Plants (Infographic)
6 Fast-Growing Plants for Natural Cleaning in Standard Aquariums
Increase or Decrease Freshwater Aquarium pH Naturally
Benefits of Montmorillonite Clay for Pond and Aquarium Fish


© All Natural Pet Care BlogGuest posts are exclusively submitted to and may not be posted elsewhere. You are welcome to link to this post for reference, discussion, etc. Content theft will result in legal action. Thank you for respecting the effort that we have put into our original content. If you would like to have quality content created for you, please contact our writer directly.

DISCLAIMER: Statements on this website may not have been evaluated by the FDA, Health Canada nor any other government regulator. The information and products provided by are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, nor prevent any disease and are intended for educational purposes only. READ MORE…

COMMENTS ARE MODERATED – Legitimate comments will be published after a short delay. Spam will not be published.

9 thoughts on “4 Questions About Aquarium Gravel That Will Make Or Break Your Tank

  1. I haven’t had much luck with plants but I still use gravel. I like how the black makes the fish look & I have a black background too. I found some big rocks on the beach that look nice in there and the fish hid around them. I’ll be buying a new cylinder aquarium soon and this post is a good guide for setting it up from step one.

    • Hello Harpreet!

      Sounds like a fun project – I love the many unique aquarium shapes there out there. I tend to stay “classic” with mine only because I love to build caves and things, and the boxy shape helps me plan those out a little more easily.

      Be careful with rocks you find at the beach — they can hold many minerals and salts that may not be beneficial to your aquarium. Also, they can soak up chemicals and pollution that has been splashed on them as they sit there — many environments are not pristine and these things can concentrate on rocks as they’re dried in the sun. Personally, I won’t even use rocks from a yard unless I’m positive the space has never been treated with chemicals or fertilizers.

      Also, be careful that the rocks do not have sharp edges. If the fish are hiding in them, they could scratch their natural slime coating, which protects them the same way our skin does for us. Once broken, they can become vulnerable to disease.

      My go-to places for aquarium rocks, if I’m not buying them, is in a wooded area, or a remote reservoir. I tend to save my rocks for years, and have built up several boxes over the decades.

      Good luck with your tanks, and thanks for sharing your comments with me! 🙂

  2. I like natural gravel and big rocks in my tanks. My first tank had pink and purple gravel LOL.

    • Francis, I find that’s the way with many aquarium owners — many start with the iconic colored gravels, but gradually progress to a more natural look. Personally, I prefer that, and feel like my fish do as well. Kind of like a person usually feels more comfortable in a room with hardwood floors than bright pink ones. 🙂

      Thanks so much for reading and commenting!

  3. I have had all types of pets when my kids were at home. I had guinea pigs, dogs, cats, fresh and saltwater aquariums. Caring for the saltwater fish was the hardest and freshwater aquariums was next. Finally gave up.

    • Peyton, I have very little experience with saltwater setups for exactly that reason — there’s so much chemistry and knowledge to it. And they’re so much more expensive; one fish dies and you could be out a hundred dollars!

      It took me a long time to get where I am with freshwater tanks — I’ve been doing them for 24 years — and I don’t think I’d migrate to saltwater setups. I get a lot of joy from what I’m already doing. 🙂

      Thanks for sharing your thoughts!

  4. I really love the last tank pictures. I am returning to aquascaping after a 20yr hoatus so your article really helped! My goal is to create a natural tank to breed shrimp in. Any shrimp types you recommend for beginners? Any type of shrimp I should avoid??? TIA!

    • Marjorie — I’m so glad you like the photos! My current aquariums are some of my all-time favorite setups. I’m also so glad I was able to help you with your own setups — I’m wishing you the best as you get back in the saddle!

      Melody is right on — cherry shrimp are a great starter species. I’d avoid trying to breed bamboo shrimp, ghost shrimp or any “Sulawesi” shrimp, which have very specific water requirements. If you don’t want to try cherry shrimp, try to get a species that is a “complex” breeder. Complex-breeding shrimp have young that hatch looking like a miniature version of a fully-mature adult. This makes raising them as easy as it gets for shrimp.

      Species like Ghost Shrimp are considered “simple” breeders, and are anything but! They have an elaborate life cycle that starts them out in a larval form and requires them to move through different salinity levels before they’re ready to live in fresh water. It’s quite a challenge to learn about and set up, and not something I’d recommend for a beginner.

      Hope this helps! Please let me know if you have any other questions! 🙂

Comments are closed.